Custom orthotics are shoe inserts made to a
prescription written for your feet. A podiatrist writes it
after examining you and watching you walk. A lab
then builds the device to match.
That takes a lot longer than picking an insole off a
pharmacy shelf. Whether the wait is worth it
depends on what's wrong with your feet.
The example below is a podiatry clinic in Canberra.
Most clinics that prescribe their own devices follow
much the same steps.
Custom vs. store-bought
Off-the-shelf insoles come in standard sizes. They add cushioning and a rough arch shape, and that's
about it. Both feet get the same shape. If your left foot rolls in further than your right, or one heel tips
outward when it lands, the insole does nothing about it.
A custom orthotic starts from a scan of your foot, with the corrections built in. That might be a wedge
under the heel, or a cutout that takes pressure off a sore spot under the ball of the foot. The American
Podiatric Medical Association draws the line in the same place: prescription orthotics are made for one
person after a medical evaluation, over-the-counter inserts for an average foot.
Who they help
Heel pain is the big one, plantar fasciitis especially. Pain under the ball of the foot comes next. Podiatrists
also prescribe them for feet that roll too far inward as you walk (overpronation), and to take pressure off a
bunion.
Then there's work. A twelve-hour shift on a hospital floor or a shop's concrete slab is hard on heels, and
nurses and retail staff often turn up at podiatry clinics because of it. Runners make up another group,
usually because their foot mechanics keep producing the same overuse injury.
The evidence is mixed. In 2006 Karl Landorf's team at La Trobe University in Melbourne published a
randomized trial in the Archives of Internal Medicine. They compared custom and prefabricated orthotics
against flat sham inserts in 135 people with plantar fasciitis. After three months, both real options had
improved function a little. Custom pairs did no better than prefabricated ones, and by twelve months
there was no clear difference between any of the groups.
So a custom pair is worth paying for in two situations. Your feet need a correction a generic insole can't
give, or you've already tried a generic insole and it didn't help.
What the assessment involves
Most of the first appointment is talking and watching. The podiatrist asks about your symptoms and what
sets them off, and looks at the shoes you wear most.
Then comes the hands-on part. They check how far each joint in your feet and legs moves, and look for
hard skin that shows where pressure lands. Last, they watch you walk, often on a gait analysis system
that records how each foot strikes the ground and pushes off.
Nothing gets made yet. Sometimes the assessment finds the real cause is tight calves or shoes that
have worn out, and orthotics wouldn't fix either.
How custom orthotics are made
Capital Podiatry, a clinic in Greenway in Canberra's Tuggeranong district, explains on its custom orthotics
in Canberra page that the 3D scan happens only after the assessment suggests orthotics will help.
The scan and the assessment findings become a prescription. A lab 3D prints the shells, then builds
them up with the corrections and a cushioned top cover. Within about two weeks you go back for a fitting,
where the podiatrist checks the pair against the prescription and adjusts it to your shoes.
Two parts matter. The shell is the firm base that holds the correction in place, and printing it from a scan
gives it the exact shape of your foot. The top cover is the soft layer you stand on.
Expect a wearing-in period. Capital Podiatry allows one to two weeks. Start with an hour or so and add a
bit more each day while your feet and legs get used to the new position. A mild ache in the arch is normal
during that time. Sharp pain isn't, and neither are blisters. Either one means the pair needs adjusting.
You don't need a referral to book an orthotics assessment there. A chronic condition management plan
from your GP can cover part of the cost of up to five allied health visits a year through Medicare, but not
the devices themselves. Private health extras cover may help with those.
How long they last
Capital Podiatry says its custom orthotics last at least five years. The top cover goes first. Once it's thin
or starts peeling, it can be replaced on its own, so you don't need a whole new pair. A pharmacy insole
worn every day usually flattens out well before that.
Feet change over five years, though. A pregnancy can change how you walk, and so can an injury. If
your old symptoms come back, get the prescription rechecked.
When a store-bought insole is enough
If your arches ache at the end of a long day and that's all, try a decent off-the-shelf insole and supportive
shoes first. Give it a few weeks. Plenty of people never need anything more.
Sometimes the fix is something else entirely. Capital Podiatry says it may recommend footwear changes,
or physio with strengthening exercises, when the cause of the pain lies elsewhere. For plantar fasciitis,
the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons puts calf and plantar fascia stretches near the top of its
list of first treatments. They're free.
If you have diabetes or poor circulation, see a podiatrist sooner. You might not feel a pressure spot
forming, and a badly fitting insert can create one that turns into a sore.
Endnote
Tried a store-bought insole for a few weeks with no change? Or the same pain keeps coming back?
Book an assessment. Ask the podiatrist what they found and why they think orthotics will help. If they say
orthotics won't help, ask what will.